What stock market anomaly is the September Effect?

September Effect

What stock market anomaly is the September Effect?

There exist multiple stock market anomalies that are discussed and debated by stock brokers and investors alike on the legitimacy of using reoccurring market patterns to beat the market.

You may have heard of some of these patterns – the January effect, the notion that poor performing stocks in the fourth quarter outperform in January. Or how about the small firm effect, where a portfolio of smaller companies tend to outperform larger companies. There is also the SANTA CLAUS RALLY, DOGS OF THE DOW, SUPER BOWL INDICATOR, SELL IN MAY GO AWAY to name a few.

So you may be wondering what effect, if any, the market will have on your investment portfolio as we head into the Fall trading season. This brings us to the latest anomaly, the September effect. You can date back 100 years or longer and discover that the month of September has delivered, historically, below average performance for stock investors.

As an investor, you may have experienced a substantial amount of your wealth rise with the market since the bull rally starting in March of 2009. And for those who are aware of the historically low performing trend in the month of September, you may be wondering if it’s time to back up the truck and take some profits.

Historically, bull and bear markets occur with the almost automatic expansion and contraction of the economy. The events that turn a bull market into a bear market and vice versa are events that economists and market analysts have studied over long periods of time. They are considered the ebb and flow of wealth accumulation. Bear markets, for instance, are viewed as normal and necessary, as they serve to “clean up” what are considered prior economic excesses.

So should you be concerned with the possibility of a pull back or a correction or worst case, a bear market?

Simply put, absolutely not! What all investors should realize is that bear markets create an excellent opportunity to buy low and sell high. It is the long-term picture that investors need to keep in mind.

Did you catch that? The answer to experiencing positive returns on your portfolio at the end of the day is simply holding your investments for the long haul. I’m sorry to disappoint those of you who anticipated a romanticized or mystical answer to beating the market, but it is basically a matter of your holding period.

Long term investing is more often about the psychological aspects of managing money and sticking to a financial plan. It is important to understand how market conditions create euphoria or fear in some people. The general rule is that market declines will inevitably always happen. Bear markets prepare the way for future bull markets. And, while investing carries specific risks, many of those risks may become more acceptable and tolerable by remembering that what is occurring in a bear market is a revaluing of securities.

Whether you can beat the market using market anomalies is up for debate. However, creating a well-diversified portfolio consistent with your goals and objectives combined with a long-term outlook and low expenses will help deliver the returns you would expect from holding an equity portfolio regardless of what month you are heading into. Happy investing!

Recent Posts

The FIRE Movement in 2026: What We Got Right – And What We Didn’t

There is still plenty of discussion surrounding the FIRE movement—Financial Independence, Retire Early—even though the concept first gained widespread attention more than a decade ago. Since then, we’ve had a front-row seat to countless success stories. Social media has celebrated thirty-somethings leaving corporate careers, traveling the world, and achieving financial freedom decades before the traditional […]

The 1% Rule: Are You Paying for Advice or Asset Size?

When people think about retirement planning, they naturally focus on their investments. After all, your portfolio is often expected to replace the paycheck you’ve relied upon for decades. But there is another factor that can have a significant impact on your long-term financial outcomes—how you pay for advice or management. For years, the wealth management […]

Why Your Financial, Investment, and Tax Plan Must Work Together

When it comes to managing your finances, many people find themselves working with multiple professionals. They may have a financial planner to help build a retirement roadmap, an investment advisor to manage their portfolio, and a tax professional to prepare their tax returns. At first glance, this arrangement seems logical. After all, each professional specializes […]